Apostasy and Death Penalty
By Abd Moqsith Ghazali
Meanwhile, no single verse of Quran declare that apostates should be killed. Allah would certainly have included this important penalty in the Quran if he wanted it performed. In fact, Quran clearly guarantees freedom of religion. Jawdat Said observed that the above hadith is dla’if (weak), since it conflicts with the fundamental Islamic teaching: namely freedom of religion.
Post a Comment
The Quran should not be understood without recourse to ahadith - the ahadith elaborate and qualify verses, and as there are ahadith on apostasy, one cannot ignore them. The principle is to take both texts where possible, and if not, the weaker is rejected. Here the two texts can be reconciled, where religion can be followed by all, however when one enters Islam they should be aware they cannot leave it…
——-
The Quran is (something the only perception of sheme process from Adam to Adam, Al Baqarah (2) v.30-39, to Al A’raaf (7) v.27, Ta Ha (20) v.117, and practiced all processed by Mohammad around the Kabah, sa’i, stay in Arafah, nightly in Musdalifah and throuwing stones at Ula, Wusta and Aqaba, according to Al Baqarah (2) v.125,158,189,196,197, Al ‘Imran (3) v.96,96, Al Ma’idah (5)v. 97, Al Hajj (22) v.26,27 etc. indecated in Isra’il (17) v. 13,14,71,72, Al An’Am (6) v.7) in a book Al Baqarah (2) v.2, that the interpretaton will come in the later day here in the world.
So the Quran will be understood perfectly by God sending (to someone in Indonesia, Ha Mim Sajdah (41) v.44) the fulfilment of a book explaination day,according to Al A’raaf (7) ayat 52,53: And surely, We have brought them a great Book (skeme from Adam of formerly to Adam of to day) which We have expounded with knowledge (Al Mujadilah (58) v.6,18,22), and which is a guidance (Al Baqarah (2) v.4,5), and a mercy for a people who believe (to the explaination/enterpretationday). Do they wait for the fulfillment of that of which it warns? On the day when that fulfilment comes, those who had neglected it before (for 8000 years, especialy the people of Muhammad for more than 1400) will say: The Messengers of our Lord did indeed bring the truth. Have we then any interceccors(from Indonesia) who will intercede for us (all the people of the world)? Or, could we be sent back (from the begining (0) of knowledge of the Quran) that we might act differently from that which we used to do (during for more that 1400 years going to asttray?They have indeed ruined their souls and that which they used to fabricate has failed them (going astray).
Salom, Soegana Gandakoesoema, Reformer of the one perception of Religion of the 3rd millennium.
I hope you are the one of the fulfilment “The Liberal Moslem”.
Comments (2)
(Displaying all comments, ascending. 20 comments per page)