Islam and Judaism

Bukhaira itu bukan Jewish, tapi seorang Nasrani. Anak SD aja tau.. Aku baru lulus SMA nih, dan aku sukaaa banget sama Soe Hok Gie (mahasiswa Indonesia keturunan Tiong Hoa yg juga aktivis), kalau aku harus memilih, aku lebih memilih Soe Hok Gie yang mengaku dirinya atheis daripada orang2 yang ngaku Islam tapi pikirannya udah terkotori / tercuci paham2 barat, itu sih kayak duri dalam daging. Islam ya Islam, Liberal ya Liberal. Konsisten dong!! Santri-santri Indonesia yang melanjutkan kuliah di Amerika pemikirannya langsung berubah mengagumi Amerika dan keliberalannya,Menurut aku sih santri-santri seperti itu (yg mudah tercuci otaknya oleh keliberalan) termasuk santri-santri karbitan yang pemahaman Al-Qurannya belum sempurna, tapi udah dicekoki pemahaman lain yang mungkin lebih kuat. Makanya sebelum pergi kuliah ke AS, sempurnakan dulu pemahaman Al-Qurannya,baru bisa ke sana. Kemarin aku baca buku tipis tentang Sayyid Qutb yg juga sama2 kuliah di AS, tapi bisa menghasilkan karya2 luar biasa di dalam penjara, padahal dia bukan santri loh..Nah, ini di Indonesia malah “santri-santri” yang menentang agamanya sendiri, karya tulisan mereka juga yaaa biasa2 aja,malah ada yang ingin mencalonkan diri jadi Presiden..Cape deh..Kenapa sih ga praktis2 aja gitu..cukup satu pemahaman aja! Islam atau Liberal. Iya,mungkin komentar saya ini terlalu lugu, saya cuma mengungkapkan yang saya ketahui tapi nurani saya bilang pemahaman dualisme itu ngga bener. Ya,mungkin tulisan saya ini tak lebih dari bunyi petasan yang tidak mengubah apapun di dalam jaringan ini, tapi kalau dapat mengubah walaupun dikit bgt alhamdulillah deh..Salam juga buat Mas Ulil, ditunggu dalam Islam Kaffah =D

So, you can explain the past. But can you give me some explaination about “the protocol for the elder of zion”? The real evil agenda’s of the jew?

The Alquran followers, as well as followers of Taurat and Injil, has given “lightened script” from above. Please do what should do. The differences would be judge on the different zone. Let’s work together. May God bless us.

Generalizing people into one frame is not wise. Some Jews also very good people who worshiping God and doing good deeds. Some of them, perhaps, also bad guys who tricky, dishonest, and have evil intention. Moslem, Christian, and other religious people also possible to be good and bad, regardless what their religion are. Even, unreligious people and atheists are wiser than religious people. For example, many people in Scandinavian countries are good; they gave alms and always tried to be the first people to give aid to disaster victim. In contrary, many people who claim themselves as religious man practice terrorism in the name of God.  Become bad or good person is individual choice, not religious granted. So, don’t judge people from their religion.

Dear Yudha,
The so-called “Protocols of the Elders of Zion” have been conclusively, solidly and repeatedly proved by non-Jewish and Jewish scholars over a 75 year period to be a forgery. It was made in Russia in the late 19th century in order to justify persecuting Jews there at the time.  See, e.g., http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Protocols_of_the_Elders_of_Zion
and many other links on the subject. If you want to argue against Zionism or Israel, please be fair enough to do so on the basis of actual policies (which should be more than enough!), not on false lies and fabrications.

any comment on recent attack of israel jews on palestinian?

To: Hamim

When God told Abram “in you all the families in the earth shall be blessed” He’s kept His word in more ways than one. He still means it.

The Jews and the Arabs - Interesting point of view.
 
The Jews are NOT promoting brain washing children in military training camps, teaching them how to blow themselves up and cause maximum deaths of Jews and other non Muslims!

The Jews don’t hijack planes, nor kill athletes at the Olympics, or blow themselves up in German restaurants.  There is NOT one single Jew that has destroyed a church.  There is NOT a single Jew that protests by killing people.

The Jews don’t traffic slaves, nor have leaders calling for Jihad and death to all the Infidels.

Perhaps the world’s Muslims should consider investing more in standard education and less in blaming the Jews for all their problems.

Muslims must ask ‘what can they do for humankind’  before they demand that humankind respects them!!

Regardless of your feelings about the crisis between Israel and the Palestinians and Arab neighbors, even if you believe there is more culpability on Israel ‘s part, the following two sentences really say it all:

‘If the Arabs put down their weapons today, there would be no more violence.
If the Jews put down their weapons today, there would be no more Israel ’ -Benjamin Netanyahu

I wasn’t surprise with your answer whatsoever. But what I am amazed with is your negative response on my question. I did not blame anybody. But if your own house being removed out of your own land or you have to pass check point every single day to go to work or even to take your own sick child to hospital, what your human feeling gonna be? I was thinking I am a moderate person before however your above response provide me with nothing but moderate nolonger.

Everyone is familiar with the Judaism&Christianity;of the Bible. Christianity has been around 2000 years&Judaism;for 4000 years. However there is a 3rd aspect of religion of the Bible&is;older than Judaism The religion of the Bible between Adam&Abraham;that other 2000 year period, also Job in the book of Job who was neither a Jew or Christian but served&worshiped;the God of the Bible. The truth is that there were various cultures in the world that had this aspect of religion in their culture, well into the 19th even 20th century. A people in Burma&Thailand;known as the Karen had this(General Revelation) until the early 19 th century when Christianity reached them. Today many are Protestant Christians. A people in Ethiopia known as the Gedeo had this religion until 1948 when Christianity came to them The book that talks about this aspect of General Revelation is Eternity In Their Hearts by Don Richardson Regal Books 1981 revised 1984 on Amazon or can be ordered at any bookstore. This folk religion of General Revelation was like a watered down version of Judaism, they were monotheistic, had no idols or images, their leader offered an animal sacrifice for the sins of the people once a year, the same as the high priest did in Judaism, and they knew that a book-(The Bible) was going to come to them.6000 years of General Revelation